News and Tribune

February 12, 2013


Concern over animal feeding operations  bill, resolution

This letter is in response to the Jan. 28 article titled “Indiana lawmakers consider protecting right to hunt.” 

The resolution being considered is SJR0021, and it sounds good, guaranteeing the right to hunt, fish and farm. But what is not mentioned in the article is the wording of this resolution which will make it illegal for any community to oppose the construction of Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations (CAFOs) and CFOs (smaller versions of CAFOs). This resolution is not about “animal rights.” It’s about the right of any community to have a say in what they will allow in their community.

There is a growing concern about the impact on human health and the environment of the industrialized animal agriculture industry, which our state legislature seems to be ignoring. Please go to and click on “Research Materials.” Another good web site to look at is, enter CAFO in the search window.

A bill was introduced in the 2011 legislature to put a moratorium on the construction of new CAFOs and CFOs or the expansion of existing CAFOs and CFOs until these issues could be resolved, but it wasn’t acted upon and it has not been reintroduced.

Another bill of concern is SB0571, which will, if passed, take away any local communities right to regulate existing animal agricultural operations. To read these bills, you can go to, click on Bill Info, then enter 0571 in the search window or click on Resolutions, then click on Joint and scroll down to SJR0021.

Although the Indiana Department of Environmental Management regulates these farms, they do not regulate location, air quality, disposal of dead animals, increased traffic or the devaluation of neighboring properties, which can be as much as 50 percent.

In my opinion, if the above resolution and bill become law, they will infringe upon the rights of the people to protect their health and their environment. If you feel the same, please contact Hoosiers for Humane Animal Agriculture at

— William Wilson, Jeffersonville


Basketball coach gives praise to Franz

I have enjoyed reading about the honors bestowed on Clarksville High School basketball legend Chuck Franz this winter. I have never met Chuck, nor did I ever see him play, except on TV when I was a kid while he played for Indiana University. 

My admiration for Mr. Franz came from something I once read in one of Steve Alford’s books. As described by Mr. Alford, early in Mr. Franz’s senior season at IU, Alford, a freshman, abruptly was told to replace Franz in the starting lineup. Franz, who had played significantly in his earlier years at IU, only played sparingly his senior year, playing behind the freshman Alford. 

Alford wrote in his book “Playing for Knight” how much he learned from Franz after he replaced him.

“I noticed how Chuck responded to the embarrassment of being replaced by a freshman ... he never pouted or got down on himself. As the days went by, he never showed any resentment toward me and he helped me in every way he could, offering me encouragement and advice with a ready smile.”

Chuck Franz, apparently, was beyond a great basketball player — he also is a great man.

— Lou Lefevre, head coach, Providence boys' basketball, Clarksville


Reader builds his case

Attention Ruthanne Wolfe [Jan. 28 letter to the editor] and all those proposing gun regulation: A man was severely beaten in New Albany by a two-by-four. Does this fact make you want to ban two-by-fours?

It would be very hard to build a house or anything without them, huh?

— Mason Gary, Clarksville