News and Tribune

June 29, 2013


Where’s the transparency?

The Greater Clark County School Board amended its agenda at the beginning of its last meeting to add the hiring of new athletic directors at Jeffersonville High School and Charlestown High School.

The two men hired, Chad Gilbert and Todd Satterly, both of whom are relatives of either current or former board members, replace Lisa Stemler and Kim Carroll, who were “involuntarily transferred,” according to Superintendent Andrew Melin.

Melin was quoted as saying, “None of this had anything to do with gender issues. It was all about moving our athletic departments to a higher level and [hiring] those people with administrative contracts to hold our athletes and coaches to a higher level of accountability.”

The new positions will be given administrative contracts rather than teaching contracts, according to Melin. In addition, the board approved job descriptions at an earlier meeting for “associate athletic directors” who will assist the athletic directors.

It appears that even though the new athletic directors have an administrator’s license, they will need an assistant to do the job previously done singularly by Ms. Stemler and Ms. Carroll. The taxpayers of Clark County should be scratching their heads on that one since money is supposedly tight and teaching positions are being cut.

While Mr. Gilbert is apparently well-qualified to be an athletic director and presumably Mr. Satterly is as well, it seems that the removal of Ms. Carroll and Ms. Stemler had no real basis other than they apparently don’t possess an administrator’s license.

I assume that the athletic director at New Washington does have this license, right? Or are we only focusing on JHS and CHS? Does New Washington count? Do we not want to hold their athletes and coaches to a “higher level of accountability” as well? And why would Dr. Melin even mention “gender” in his comments if he didn’t feel that discrimination might be an issue?

Although Mr. Gilbert was recently quoted as saying he is happy for the “opportunity” to return to his alma mater (CHS), it appears that this “opportunity” was not a real opportunity at all, but a position that was created by involuntarily removing someone who was well respected and doing a good job. To involuntarily remove someone just to create an opening for someone else is not an “opportunity,” but a travesty. While I wish Mr. Gilbert and Mr. Satterly well in their new positions, this is not the way that I would want to obtain a new job.

And, lastly, why were these positions added at the last minute to the agenda on the night of the board meeting? It is quite hard to believe that the people hired for these positions were not known in time to get placed in the board documents. This tactic was also used for the hiring of two new maintenance/groundskeeper positions that were highly controversial.

The public deserves better than this.

— Alice Butler, Jeffersonville


What we have forgotten


I like many American citizens are wondering where, what and when we lost control over our elected leaders.

Back in 2010, I ran as a write-in candidate for the 9th Congressional District in the state of Indiana. Now I knew I was not going to win the election, but I wanted to show people that we still had the right to run in this country without spending millions.

Now back in that election, I pointed out that we would hear the very same things in each and every election cycle. We will save Social Security and we will save Medicaid and Medicare and will not spend this nation into oblivion but, tell me do you think they have kept their promises?

Now we have been faced with facts that our government [both parties] have used the CIA, NSA, DOJ and let us not forget the IRS on us, we the people. Some people are not alarmed yet. What will it take to wake you up to the loss of your freedoms or your privacy?

I ran because our nation was founded on people of the common cause who would seek an office and serve a term and then we would live under the laws we passed. That in our service to this nation, we would not allow this country to become second to any other nation of this world and that a citizen would be part of the fabric that would make this country strong.

In these times, we are reminded by our elected leaders that that we are a country or immigrants and that has made this nation great. The facts that are left out by both parties are that not only did they come here for a new start, they came to become part of this nation. They knew the laws and they strived to become citizens of this nation. They made no demands to change the language or to impose their will on their new country.

What I am asking for is that you the reader take a look around and find those who are willing to run outside of the party line; those who will do what is needed to make sure that this country survives not for a party but as a people.

If it is so hard for us to understand Washington D.C. and how it works that we feel we must elect only those who spend millions to make $100,000, then what we do not understand anymore is why this country came to be.

We escaped a ruling class so each person would be able to rule themselves, and it this thought we have lost. It is just my thoughts and how I feel so I will speak up because when we remain silent, you will never be heard.

— Jerry R. Lucas, Deputy